Add this fun 4-Way Thanksgiving Pie to your holiday baking list this year!

4-Way Thanksgiving Pie
Can’t decide which pie to make for Thanksgiving? Why choose just one when you can have FOUR?! This fun 4-Way Thanksgiving Pie combines four classic pie flavors into one delicious dessert.
We think it’s perfect for smaller families, smaller Thanksgiving gatherings, or anyone who wants a little taste of everything without making four entire pies!
It’s easier to put together than you might think. If I can make this, YOU totally can too!
Ingredients:
- Pie crust (I used store-bought to keep things simple!)
- Apple pie filling (I used canned)
- Cherry pie filling (I used canned)
- Pumpkin pie filling
- Pecan pie filling
Feel free to switch up the flavors and use your family’s favorite pie fillings!
Don’t let the four sections intimidate you! This pie is easier to assemble than it looks. The biggest trick is taking your time and keeping your pie dough nice and cold. Here’s how to put it all together!

How to Make a 4-Way Pie:
Lay your pie crust into your pie plate, pressing it gently into the bottom and sides. You’ll want enough crust around the edges to hold all four sections.
Cut two thick strips of pie dough, making them tall enough to reach the height of your pie plate. Lay the strips across the center of your pie to create four separate sections, like a plus sign (+).
Press the bottom edges of the dividers into the bottom crust as best you can to help seal the sections together.

Place your divided pie crust in the refrigerator for about an hour. This is an important step! Working with the dough and shaping your dividers will warm it up, so you’ll want to give it plenty of time to get cold and firm up again. This helps the dividers hold their shape when you add the fillings.
While your pie crust is chilling, prepare your pecan pie filling and pumpkin pie filling according to your recipes. Have your apple and cherry pie fillings ready to go, too!
Once your pie crust is nice and cold, it’s time to add the fillings!

- Apple pie filling in one quarter
- Cherry pie filling in the opposite quarter
- Pecan pie filling in the third quarter
- Pumpkin pie filling in the remaining quarter
Here’s a little trick that helped me: I used popsicle sticks and toothpicks to help hold up the pie dough dividers while carefully adding each filling. This helps keep the sections separated and prevents the dividers from falling over as you work!

I added a simple lattice pie crust topping over the apple and cherry sections. You can leave the pecan and pumpkin sections open so each flavor has its own look.
Place your pie in an oven preheated to 375°F. Bake for at least 45 minutes (mine took about an hour), checking for doneness along the way.
About halfway through baking, loosely cover the pie with aluminum foil to keep the top from getting too brown while the fillings finish baking.
Once baked, allow the pie to cool before slicing and serving. Then enjoy a little taste of all four Thanksgiving favorites in one delicious dessert!

One of my favorite things about this recipe is that you can customize it based on what your family loves. Don’t love one of these four flavors? Swap it out for something else!
And who says this has to be just a Thanksgiving dessert? I’m already thinking about all the possibilities for other holidays! You could make an Easter version with different fruit fillings, try a key lime pie section, or come up with your own fun combination.
Looking for more unique Thanksgiving sides to add to your menu this season? Check out these other recipes on the blog!
These Cinnamon Roll Turkeys are Perfect for Breakfast on Thanksgiving!
These Pumpkin Pie Cheese & Crackers are the Best Thanksgiving Appetizer!


Leave a Reply