Reese’s Peanut Butter Cake


I found this recipe over here.


If you have a peanut butter lover at home . . .


Roll up your sleeves and get to work. 🙂 

My sweet Caroline found this recipe over on Pinterest and was convinced it was just for her,

and since she doesn't ask that often for much, I happily obliged.

I'd made this one for her last year (clearly one of my favorites . . . )

But this one (quite literally) takes the cake.


Head on over HERE for directions, and let me know what you think!


(Note: the only thing I changed was making this a regular 2 layer cake instead of 4 layers as she suggests in the recipe. Honestly? Four layers would have been considered plain old ridiculous grace at our house, but two layers were a wee bit of heaven!) 🙂 


Looking for more birthday cake inspiration?


Print Friendly and PDF


  1. Thank you for making and sharing my Peanut Butter Cake recipe! (Also a favourite in this house… the chocolate cake recipe in particular is my go-to!) The drip looks amazing, and the top of yours looks so beautiful and colourful with the pieces and half-cups. Gorgeous 🙂

Speak Your Mind