CHEAPEST Amazon Subscribe & Save Items – Our Fave 15 Under $3!



Amazon Subscribe & Save Items under $2

Amazon's Subscribe & Save program is a great way to save EXTRA on household and healthy and beauty items.  You”ll always save 5% by choosing subscribe & save, but you'll save a hefty 15% instead if you're able to find a total of FIVE Amazon Subscribe & Save items you want.

It can be a hassle to find other subscribe & save items to get to get up to five – so here are some of Amazon's CHEAPEST Subscribe & Save items!  (Remember – you can cancel your subscription after the first shipment ships!)

Please leave a comment if you find some great options under $2 as well – and we'll add them to this list 🙂

Amazon CHEAPEST Subscribe & Save Items – Under $2

  1. Bic Atlantis Pen 4-pk

  2. Reynolds Slow Cooker Liners

  3. Maybelline New York Baby Lips Balm

  4. Reynolds Kitchen Pre-Cut Parchment Paper Baking Sheets 22ct

  5. Avery Foil Star Labels 440 pk

  6. Garnier Fructis Leave-In Conditioner

  7. Goodsense Ibuprofen 50ct

  8. Luden's 20-ct Throat Drops, Menthol

  9. Revlon Kiss Balm, Fresh Strawberry

  10. Lysol 6-ct Toilet Bowl Cleaners

  11. Sally Hansen Extreme Hard as Nails Polish

  12. EOS Visibly Soft Lip Balm Sphere

  13. Maybelline Twin Eyebrow and Eyeliner Pencils

  14. Snuggle Exhilarations Dryer Sheets, Island Hibiscus and Rainflower 70ct

  15. Burt's Bees Eye Makeup Remover Pads


See more Amazon Deals – learn why we love Amazon Prime for buying normal household items here!

Join Amazon Prime for one month free – Watch Over 40,000 Movies for free plus get free shipping on thousands of items


Print Friendly and PDF


  1. Most of these are not subscribe and save anymore… BOO!

  2. Yeah, this list definitely needs to be updated!

  3. How much does it cost to subscribe?

    • Hi Donna! There is no additional fee to subscribe to an item, and you can cancel at any time! Just select Subscribe & Save on the product page! 🙂 Hope that helps!

Speak Your Mind