Mix all ingredients together until smooth.
Drop mixture onto a sheet of plastic wrap. Wrap around, forming into the shape of a ball. Let chill 30-60 minutes to form.
Unwrap and roll cheese ball into Everything Bagel seasoning, pressing a little to cover evenly.
Re-wrap in plastic wrap and add rubber bands or string to the outside to create the creases of a pumpkin. Chill again for 15-20 minutes.
Remove from plastic wrap and bands and serve cold to maintain shape.