What’s for Dessert? Robbie’s Perfect Peanut Butter Pie

I don't know about you, but the meals that people brought me when I came home from the hospital with each of my new babies were my favorite meals ever.  After my Caroline was born, the Minister of Education at our church brought us this perfectly perfect peanut butter pie, and I've been waiting for the stars to line up (a.k.a. the coupon matchups to line up . . . ) to share it with you! 

It takes about 5 minutes to throw together, and is a perfect cool treat during these fleeting days of summer (I'm itching to start working on fall recipes, but I'm trying to be patient!)  Here's what you'll need . . .

8 oz. cream cheese softened We used fat free, Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese On Sale $1.25, use $5/5 Kraft Cheese or Dairy Products

1 tub Cool Whip We used light, could also use Publix brand if it's cheapest

Chocolate Graham Cracker Crust It's definitely cheapest to make your own, but I confess that I bought mine at Publix for $1.99!

1 cup powdered sugar Use $0.50/2 Domino Sugar Products 8/29/2010 RP Insert (exp 11/30/2010), $0.30/1 Domino Sugar Product

3/4 cup peanut butter Peter Pan Peanut Butter BOGO $2.47, use $1/2 Peter Pan Peanut Butter All You (exp 10/31/2010)

1/4 cup milk I used skim

Beat cream cheese until light and fluffy.  Add peanut butter and powdered sugar, mix well.  Slowly add in milk, again, mix until well blended.  Gently fold in Cool Whip, and pour into graham cracker crust.  Drizzle with chocolate syrup or a little shaved chocolate, if desired.  YUMMMMM! 

Note – if you choose to use low fat ingredients like we did, this will not be as firm a pie as the original recipe.  I was totally fine with that,  but if you like a thicker peanut butter pie you might want to use regular cream cheese, cool whip, and at least 2 percent milk!

Thanks so much to I Heart Publix and Two Thrifty Sisters for the coupon matchups, and check out $5 Dinner Mom for bargain meal deals.  If you need some more menu inspiration, you can also visit the Recipe Index or join Passionate Penny Pincher on Facebook to keep up with all the meals and deals!

This post is linked to Tasty Tuesday,  Tempt My Tummy Tuesday, & Saving Money Living Life's Fabulous Friday.  Check these sites out for more yummy treats!

Print Friendly and PDF


  1. Oh yum!! Peanut Butter Pie is so Heavenly! I love to take recipes and healthify…at least as much as you can. 😉

    And I agree, I have received some of the most delicious meals after a couple surgeries from friends and Church.


  2. ok i made this in like 2 minutes & it was a hit. i didn’t use any milk & i just dumped it all in & mixed it by hand. it was still a little soft but yummy. cost 3.00 as i also bought the crust & the cool whip & had everything else

  3. That’s fabulous JJ! I’m so glad you all liked it – and you can’t beat the price! Thanks so much for letting me know – we ate more tonight and I gotta stop! 🙂

    Amber – I think any food that someone else cooks just tastes better – thank goodness for sweet church folks!

  4. You had me at pie! Yum! Peanut butter rocks, I’m saving this recipe, thanks!

  5. Yum! Super simple and with the peanut butter in it – it has to be healthy right?!

  6. Oh my. You had me at peanut butter! 🙂 Thanks for the recipe and linking to Tempt My Tummy Tuesday.

Speak Your Mind